← Studio tools
Wren · Volume Seven · Studio

The Studio Playbook twelve practices, one card each

Twelve seasons of making practices, one card each: a mark beside yesterday's, an edge you cannot watch, a figure you can check, ten minutes you cannot correct, a copied page, a timed scale, a color square, a floor you sweep yourself, a held pitch, one vowel on one breath, pages before breakfast, and the date. Every number comes from the seasons' own sourcing. What each finding can't tell you is on the card too. Nothing here scores what you make. All twelve cards come with a free tool, and every one of these practices also works with paper, a pen and a clock.

The whole volume, in one day

A day in the studio

What the record supports at each point of an ordinary making day. Each box points to the card that backs it and the free tool that keeps it. Green boxes rest on the volume's two cleanest rows: the only practice with a real literature, and the only one nobody made a promise about.

From the first page before breakfast to the date before midnight

Each of these leaves a small dated thing and nothing else. Pick one or two; nobody in these seasons did all of them.

  1. First thingWrite before you read
    • Fast, without correcting, before you speak to anybody
    • A date and a page count
    • Read them back once, on purpose, weeks later, or never
    Card 11 · Pages
  2. A few minutesOne mark, one square
    • One letter down a page, or one circle, beside yesterday's sheet
    • Ninety seconds on one color, then one word
    • No score, no chart
    Cards 1, 7 · Mark, Color
  3. At the instrumentOne named scale, timed
    • One scale, etude or page of an exercise
    • Go daily, go small, and do not jump
    • No hours total and no streak
    Card 6 · Scales
  4. At the tableAn edge, a figure, a page, ten minutes
    • Eyes on the edge, not on the sheet
    • One compass construction, checkable by the sixth arc
    • A master's page and your copy, side by side
    • Ten minutes with a pen that does not lift
    Cards 2, 3, 4, 5 · Contour, Compass, Hand, Copy
  5. Somewhere loudA held pitch, one vowel
    • Ten to twenty minutes against a fixed reference
    • One vowel for one exhale, ten times
    • A date and a duration, never an accuracy
    Cards 9, 10 · Drone, Sing
  6. Same daylightMake it, then sweep it yourself
    • Loose material that cannot be kept
    • A photograph of the thing and of the cleared ground
    • Nobody else's design
    Card 8 · Wreck
  7. Before midnightThe date and one mark
    • A form you fixed once
    • Finished inside the day
    • A record that can show a miss without ending
    Card 12 · Date
Part one · hype 3

The claim ran ahead, and the practice is still there

Five practices where the popular version promises more than the record supports, and where the record still has something under the practice itself: a small trial, a nearby study, or, once, a real literature.

Card 1 · The Mark
Cost 2Evidence 2Hype 3

One mark a day, beside yesterday's sheet

A sheet on its own says nothing, and a sheet beside last week's says where your hand has drifted. The one trial in the territory is thirty-one older patients and a screening score.

Eight weeks of calligraphy against nothing (Hong Kong, 2011, change in screening score)

Calligraphy, 14 people No practice, 17 people +2.36-0.41 -10+1+2

Thirty-one people aged sixty-five and over with mild cognitive impairment, p = 0.005. A larger Hong Kong trial later found the same direction on attention and working memory.

The measure: height of the alif in dots, as later manuals describe it

Muhaqqaq8
Thuluth7
Tawqi6

The dot is the size your own pen makes. If the alif is meant to be seven dots and yours is nine, you can see it the next morning.

729The Nara Office of Sutra Transcription was formalized. Until it shut in 776 it logged rations, work requests and time-off petitions, not dated marks to watch a copyist change.
1950Albers began one format, nested squares, and painted it until his death, with the pigment and the manufacturer written on the back. He called the scheme a cooking pot.
1971Suzuki's captions give Sengai's circle the infinite and the universe and no breath at all. Sengai's own inscription: eat this and have a cup of tea.
2007The earliest print instance this book could verify of the wording about one breath and a readable mind.
The sheetOne letter down a page until the page is full, or one circle, or one short text copied out, dated.
Beside itLast week's sheet. The filing is how the practice tells you anything.
The measureA dot cut from your own pen, or a finger's width. It is not a grade; it makes a small difference visible.

Thirty-one elderly patients and a screening score is a long way from what the marketing sells. No trial in this territory has tested consciousness, and no monastery in the record kept a file of dated marks to watch the maker change.

Use it: the free toolMark →One repeated mark a day, kept beside yesterday's sheet. No score, no streak, no judgment of the mark.

Kwok et al. 2011 · Lowe 2012 · Suzuki 1927, 1971 · Seo 2007 · Albers Foundation · Season 1

Card 2 · The Contour
Cost 2Evidence 1Hype 3

Eyes on the edge, not on the page

The exercise was printed in 1941 with no brain in it. A hemisphere was attached in 1979, and 1,011 resting brains in 2013 showed no left-brained or right-brained people.

How long a contour study runs, by who set it (minutes)

Edwards: a timer5
Nicolaides: a study30
Nicolaides: longer60
Exercise 17300

The twenty-minute drill with the pen never lifting is in neither book. The number you were given is a classroom's convenience.

Teachers who endorsed the left brain, right brain statement (2012, 242 teachers)

British91%
Dutch86%
1941A full pass over the 237 scanned pages of Nicolaides' book returns zero hits for "brain" and zero for "hemisphere."
1997Four experiments found most drawing error comes from misperceiving the object rather than from the hand. It fits the exercise and was not a test of it.
1999The revised edition of the 1979 book concedes the mechanism: "For reasons that are still unclear, Pure Contour Drawing is one of the key exercises in learning to draw."
20131,011 resting brains: nine left-lateralized hubs and eleven right-lateralized ones, and no left-brained or right-brained people.
The lookFix your eye on one point of the edge and move the pencil at the same speed. Do not draw in the moments you look down.
No correctingNo eraser and no finishing. Halfway round is fine.
The sheetDated and kept, so what your hand did in February can sit beside June.

No controlled trial of this exercise was found in the indexed literature. Art teachers have kept it for eighty-five years, which is evidence of a kind, and it is the only kind there is.

Use it: the free toolContour →The page hides the line while you draw it and shows the sheet when the timer ends. A looking pass is kept as its own dated sheet.

Nicolaides 1941 · Cohen & Bennett 1997 · Edwards 1979, 1999 · Dekker et al. 2012 · Nielsen et al. 2013 · Season 2

Card 5 · The Copy
Cost 3Evidence 2Hype 3

The source page and your copy, side by side

The plates were sold in 1868 with one claim: they were hard. The teaching method sold with them now was written in 2003.

The course, in three parts (plates)

After casts70
After the masters60
Charcoal exercises60

Call it about two hundred plates. Three reputable sources give three counts, and Ackerman's own parts add to 190 against his introduction's 197.

How the method got attached

1868The brochure: no concessions to the pretty or the pleasant
1873Part three completed. Issued without a word of instruction
1991Two more complete sets surface, beside the one known
2001The revival's teachers write about model-bound students
2003A reprint, with teaching instructions written that year
1880Sixty copied charcoal sheets, finished by the seventh of September, a fortnight into the first of them, in a mining village. He sent for them again seven weeks before he died.
TangThe most revered calligraphy in China is a tracing, made by a named man who was not the author, and it loses nothing by it.
1979Practice blocked and repeated is better on the day, worse a week later, and worse again on anything new.
201535 people: eleven weeks of an introductory drawing and painting course improved blind-rated gesture drawing against chemistry students, t = 3.06, p = 0.003.
The pairThe source page and your copy, dated, with nothing measured between them.
A month of pairsThe same wrong instinct about where a shoulder sits, sheet after sheet, until you can see it.
Three wordsMo, the tracing. Lin, the freehand copy with the model in view. Fang, in the manner of.

That the master's eye arrives in your hand has not been tested in two hundred years, in drawing or in jazz. The 2015 result is about studio instruction, not copying, and it is the nearest the record gets.

Use it: the free toolCopy →The source page and your copy, dated, with no overlay, no difference map and no fidelity score.

Ackerman & Parrish 2003 · van Gogh letter 157 · Shea & Morgan 1979 · Schlegel et al. 2015 · Season 5

Card 6 · The Scales
Cost 3Evidence 3Hype 3

One named scale, timed, with no hours total

The only practice in this volume with a real literature behind it, and the literature says practice matters a modest amount. Ten thousand hours is not in the paper it is attributed to.

Share of performance differences explained by deliberate practice (2014, 88 studies)

Games26%
Music21%
Sports18%
Education4%
Professions<1%

Among elite athletes, in 2016: 1 percent.

Hours of practice alone by age eighteen, in the 1993 paper

Best violinists7,410
Good violinists5,301
Music teachers3,420

There is no sentence in the 1993 paper stating that the best violinists had ten thousand hours.

1873Hanon paid to print his own book, with the promise in italics: five fingers equally trained would be "ready to execute anything written for the instrument."
1993The same paper the number is pinned to warned: "disregard of the effort constraint on deliberate practice leads to injury and even failure."
2018357 amateurs in eleven Dutch student orchestras: 67.8 percent reported a playing-related complaint in the past twelve months.
2019A double-blind replication with 39 violinists could not put the three groups back in rank order, and still found practice explaining about a quarter of the difference.
DailyOne named thing: a scale, an etude or a page of an exercise, timed and dated.
SmallGo daily, go small, and do not jump. The risk the evidence can see is a sudden increase in playing time, not a steady amount.
No totalNo hours total, no streak, no running count.

Timed daily technical work builds a specific motor skill, at a measurable price in hands. Nobody has shown that technical facility becomes music, and nobody has run the study that would tell us. Nothing here is medical advice.

Use it: the free toolScales →A timer and the name of what you practiced. Deliberately no hours total, and nothing that rewards duration.

Hanon 1873 · Ericsson, Krampe & Tesch-Romer 1993 · Macnamara, Hambrick & Oswald 2014 · Macnamara, Moreau & Hambrick 2016 · Kok et al. 2018 · Macnamara & Maitra 2019 · Season 6

Card 11 · The Pages
Cost 2Evidence 1Hype 3

Write first thing, fast, without correcting

The instruction is ninety-two years old in print. The promise of a path to higher creativity was added in 1992, and thirty-four years later nobody has tested it.

Records found, 20 September 2026

Expressive writing, registered studies129
Morning pages, registered studies0
Expressive writing, Europe PMC2,166
Morning pages, Europe PMC6

None of the six is a study of the practice. Zero in ERIC, and the phrase is absent from PubMed's index.

Three teachers, three doses

1934Brande: count the words and push the total up gradually until it has doubled
1973Elbow: ten minutes, three times a week
1992Cameron: three pages, longhand, every morning
1934Brande's chapter seven tells you to go back after some weeks and read the accumulated mornings coldly. The modern practice reverses it.
1992"Sold over six million copies to date," by the author's own account. It measures sales.
1998Five trademark applications on the book's title. One was abandoned in 2000; the four that registered were cancelled between 2007 and 2010.
2006146 randomized studies of a different protocol, fifteen minutes on four nights about the worst thing that happened to you, pooled at r = .075: roughly a seventh of a standard deviation.
First thingBefore you have spoken to anybody or read anything. Paper and a clock set earlier.
The doseThree pages, or ten minutes three times a week, or a word count pushed up slowly. The number is yours to set.
LaterRead them yourself on purpose, once, weeks on. Or never, and know that is the 1992 version.

Nothing has tested the morning practice itself. The 146 studies tested a different protocol, and this card does not borrow their number. The missing test is a fact about the promise on the cover, not about the people who bought the book.

Use it: the free toolPages →A date and a page count. It seals what you wrote and holds it closed until you open it on purpose, weeks later.

Brande 1934 · Elbow 1973 · Cameron 1992 · Frattaroli 2006 · USPTO records · Season 11

Part two · hype 4

The explanation was invented whole

Six practices whose popular meaning was not an overstatement of what the maker said. It was supplied later, complete, by somebody who was not making anything. An explanation invented whole does not come in a small size. The practices underneath are still worth doing.

Card 3 · The Compass
Cost 2Evidence 1Hype 4

One construction a day, and the sixth arc lands or it misses

A compass figure is the rare practice you can check at a kitchen table. The golden Parthenon, the mystical lineage and the lunar labyrinth were all supplied later.

The Parthenon, measured, against the golden ratio

golden 1.618 width/height 2.25 apex height 1.71 1.52.02.5

Neither measurement is anywhere near 1.618. The ratio's name dates to 1835, and the photographs that prove it are cropped.

The lunar arithmetic, from a 1973 article

112cuspsaround the Chartres labyrinth, divided by 428daysthe "lunar" month that division gives29.5306daysthe average synodic month, which medieval clerics knew
888Stephanos the clerk finished copying Euclid and dated it. The first proposition never proves that the two circles meet.
ScrollThe Topkapi scroll: 29.5 meters long, 114 drawings, no writing, date or watermark, construction lines scored with a stylus so they would not show.
2007The quasicrystal paper printed its own limit: 11 mismatches out of 3700 tiles, and "strictly speaking," not self-similar.
2022Mandala coloring, 8 studies, 578 participants: no significantly greater drop in anxiety than free drawing, and the weakest studies reported the biggest effects.
Twenty minutesA compass, a straightedge, a sheet and a date: the two circles, the triangle, the hexagon, the rosette, the tile grid.
The checkThe sixth arc lands on the first mark or misses by the width of a pencil. If it misses you know something about your hands today.
The floorWhat the record shows people doing on a cathedral labyrinth: the canons of Auxerre throwing a leather ball across it on Easter afternoon, from at least 1396 until 1538.

There is no controlled trial of daily compass work, and there is unlikely ever to be one. A 2026 review of labyrinth walking found 25 articles across a quarter century and concluded the evidence base remains limited.

Use it: the free toolCompass →One construction from a fixed thirty, named and dated, drawn on paper and photographed if you want it kept. It never says what a figure means.

Euclid I.1, MS. D'Orville 301 · Necipoglu 1995 · Lu & Steinhardt 2007 · Markowsky 1992 · Critchlow 1973 · Season 3

Card 4 · The Hand
Cost 1Evidence 1Hype 4

Ten minutes, a pen that does not lift

The hand really does move with nobody steering it, and the mechanism was named in 1852. The prophecy attached to the most famous practitioner ran twenty-two years late because nobody wanted the work.

The twenty-year instruction, as it played out

1932An X marked in the notebooks: twenty years from her death
1944She dies, which makes the date 1964
1964Nothing happens
1970Offered to Moderna Museet, and refused
1986First public showing, in Los Angeles
2018New York: over 600,000 people come

Asking a pendulum a simple visual question (2017, percent correct)

Study 1, spoken57%
Study 1, pendulum53%
Study 2, spoken51%
Study 2, pendulum50%

Poor in both channels, and at chance in the second study.

1852Carpenter named ideo-motor action in March, to give a scientific account of fashionable phenomena.
1853Faraday put a light lever under the sitters' hands, and the effects stopped the moment they could see the index.
1924A Paris manifesto threw out everything about the practice except the instructions, and wrote the ban on correcting into the definition.
1998Forty facilitators produced messages for a woman who was not writing them. Eighty-nine percent carried information only the facilitator had.
Ten minutesA pen, a sheet, a hand that keeps moving, a date in the corner.
The ruleNo lifting and no correcting. Four incompatible accounts of who was drawing all agree on this one rule.
AfterwardKeep the sheet. Let no machine and no stranger tell you where it came from.

There is no controlled evidence that ten minutes of a moving hand does anything to you at all. It is not a channel, not a diagnosis and not a message. The one cost the season documents is being told what your drawing means.

Use it: the free toolHand →Ten uncorrected minutes. No undo, no erase, no saving over, and it never tells you what the drawing looks like.

Carpenter 1852 · Faraday 1853 · Breton 1924 · Burgess et al. 1998 · Olson, Jeyanesan & Raz 2017 · Hilma af Klint Foundation · Season 4

Card 7 · Color
Cost 1Evidence 1Hype 4

One square, ninety seconds, one word

The color and mood chart descends from a 1905 book whose plates were painted to verbal direction. The largest study of color and emotion found that people agree about words.

How closely color-word feelings agree (2020, 4,598 people, 30 nations, r)

.88 each nation vs world .78 nation vs nation .50.751.00

Agreement about which feeling word goes with which color name, in twenty-two languages. A real and large finding, and a finding about words.

The date, too, was supplied downstream

1901The year everyone prints. There was no 1901 edition
1905The first edition
1925A reprint's verso: "First Printed 1901 Reprint 1905 Reprint 1925"
1905Two people said what they perceived and three hired friends painted it. The book's own apology: they needed colored fire and had only ground earths.
KeyBlack for malice, brown for avarice, yellow for intellect: carried in whole from an earlier book and asserted, with no procedure and no test.
1911Kandinsky's light blue is a flute and darker blue a cello; four pages later the violin is green and red. He footnoted it: the parallel is only relative.
1923Itten resigned from the Bauhaus in April. His seven contrasts survived because they are about the eye.
Ninety secondsOne color. The last thirty seconds are where the eye fatigues and the color starts to move.
One wordWritten down with the date. It records what you reached for. It is not a diagnosis of you.
The contrastsSimultaneous contrast happens to you whether or not you believe anything.

In a hundred and twenty years nobody has shown that the color key means anything. Agreeing on a word is not the color meaning anything, and the review of the field says the literature remains at a nascent stage of development.

Use it: the free toolColor →A swatch, ninety seconds, one word, a date. It never maps a color to a feeling and never draws a chart.

Besant & Leadbeater 1905 · Kandinsky 1911 · Itten 1961 · Elliot & Maier 2014 · Jonauskaite et al. 2020 · Season 7

Card 8 · The Wreck
Cost 3Evidence 1Hype 4

Make it, then clear it with your own hands

Three traditions make things and take them apart, and none of them teaches the lesson this practice is sold with. That lesson was supplied by a museum crowd in New York in 1988.

Hard Earth, 27 October 1884: one day's picture, in Matthews' hours

made on the floor carried out 7:0010:002:30 pm

Made and gone inside the same daylight, and the going was not a shrug.

What each one is for, in its own record

Iikaah→A healing rite with a patient in it, taken apart in a fixed order with a song
Mandala→A consecration; the deities are asked to go home before a grain is touched
Kolam→Rice flour at a threshold to greet Lakshmi and Bhudevi and to feed ants
1953An American erased a drawing he had asked for, framed it and kept it. A museum bought it forty-five years later, in 1998.
1988The first mandala in the west built in public: six weeks, more than fifty thousand people. The talk of impermanence came when visitors asked how it would be preserved.
2008The Navajo Nation's adopted policy: traditional Diné do not make permanent records or representations of sacred or ceremonial sandpaintings.
Kolam"I went looking for a doctrine of impermanence in the kolam and did not find one." It vanishes because it is powder on a step.
The materialSand, flour, chalk, cut paper, anything that goes down without fixing.
The dayMade and cleared inside the same daylight. A task with a start and an end in one day is rare.
The recordA photograph of the thing, a photograph of the cleared ground, the date. The sweeping is yours.

There is no trial, scale, measure or number for any of the three traditions or for the modern practice: an absent finding, not a weak one. Draw no design that is not yours to draw. The Navajo Nation's exclusion is stated in its own words and is not a score.

Use it: the free toolWreck →Two photographs, the thing and the cleared ground, and the entry does not close without the second.

Matthews 1887 · Navajo Nation Historic Preservation Department 2008 · Namgyal Monastery · Nagarajan 2018 · SFMOMA 98.298 · Season 8

Card 9 · The Drone
Cost 3Evidence 2Hype 4

A pitch that holds, and your voice against it

Against a reference that does not move, every wobble in your voice becomes audible. The ancient frequencies come from a 1999 book, printed in a unit named in 1935.

Concert pitch for A, in hertz

440 432 422439450 Hollow: the 1939 compromise candidates

440 was issued as a recommendation in 1955, approved by 17 of 33 member bodies, and as a standard in 1975. No controlled evidence was found that 432 does anything 440 does not.

Where the other numbers came from

1000sThe syllables: a monk's mnemonic for positions in a six-note hexachord
1935The unit, hertz, is named
1939London, May: five delegations in a broadcasting building
1999A book presents six values as recovered from verse numbers in Numbers
1910Raga time was published across four Marathi volumes, 1910 to 1932, by a Bombay lawyer. It is not observed the same way in the south.
1921Raman described the tanpura's bridge: the cotton makes the string graze the wood, and the contact point creeps up the slope for three to ten seconds as the note dies.
1999Thirty Western listeners heard joy, sadness and anger above chance in twelve alap excerpts and missed peace. Tempo and melodic complexity explained 91 percent of the joy and sadness ratings.
202365 performances tested against the clock: only pitch features predicted the time slot, and tempo did not.
The referenceA fixed pitch: a string, a fork or a tone. Ten to twenty minutes.
The voiceFind the unison, leave it on purpose, come back.
The recordA date and a duration. Not a tuning accuracy, which would be a score.

The effect the record supports is perceptual: a steady reference makes small deviations audible. On 432 the season prints an absence, not an acquittal. A raga is a magnificent structure and not a mood delivery device.

Use it: the free toolDrone →A pitch that holds, and a timer. It keeps the minutes and never the accuracy.

Raman 1921 · Bhatkhande 1910 to 1932 · Balkwill & Thompson 1999 · Agrawal et al. 2023 · ISO/R 16, 1955 · Season 9

Card 10 · The Sing
Cost 3Evidence 2Hype 4

One vowel, one exhale, ten times

Slow recitation changed heart rhythms in a small 2001 study whose authors chose the word possibly. The harmonic you hunt was in your tone the whole time.

Baroreflex sensitivity, 23 healthy adults (2001, ms/mm Hg)

Before9.5
Reciting, six a minute11.5

The rosary and a yoga mantra. The authors' conclusion: "favourable psychological and possibly physiological effects."

How old the ancient sound is

1833Benedictines move into Solesmes, 11 July
1883The abbey prints its reconstruction from the manuscripts
1903Pius X's motu proprio on sacred music, 22 November
1963The Council gives chant pride of place, article 116
1968A monk of the same abbey attacks its rhythmic method
1994An album reissued from tapes made years earlier
2005The abbey takes its added signs out of its own books
19649 December, one session: the saxophone recites the sleeve poem, one note for each syllable. The player called it "a narration of the theme."
1991The story of monks who fell ill when they stopped chanting appears in an interview in a 1991 anthology. No abbey, no date, no number, no medical record.
1999Imaging of the vocal tract: the harmonic comes from the rear cavity, and the calculated formant sat within thirty-six cents of the melody pitch.
2013"Singing demands a slower than normal respiration," and in unison singers' hearts speed and slow together. A finding about breathing.
The exhaleOne comfortable pitch on one vowel for the length of one breath, ten times.
The vowelNarrow it and hunt the harmonic. Your rear cavity slides across a partial that was already there.
The recordA count of exhales and a date.

Twenty-three healthy adults, and the authors wrote possibly. Nobody has tested an altered state, in either direction. Nobody alive has heard medieval chant.

Use it: the free toolSing →A live spectrum and a count of exhales. Nothing about what the harmonic means.

Bernardi et al. 2001 · Vickhoff et al. 2013 · Adachi & Yamada 1999 · Sacrosanctum Concilium 1963 · Porter 1985, 1998 · Season 10

Part three · hype 1

Nobody attached a promise

The volume's control case. Four people made the date itself the work, and none of them said it would improve them. There is nothing to strip.

Card 12 · The Date
Cost 1Evidence 1Hype 1

The date and one mark, finished inside the day

Four people kept this for at least a combined century and not one of them claimed it improved them. The cleanest record in the book prints its misses.

A year of punching a time clock every hour: the misses, out of 8,760

Slept through94
Late29
Early10

He missed 1.52 percent of the punches, and printed the percentage himself.

Four files

c. 3,000datesover forty-eight years233canvaseslast number 5,607,2498,760photosone per hour punched1,590sheetsone work, 1880 to 1983
19664 January, New York: the first of the date paintings.
1968The painter counting to infinity added the camera and the tape recorder three years in, and the exclusive commitment five years in.
2014The date painter died on 10 July and the series closed behind him. He did not retire in 2013.
RuleFinished by midnight or destroyed: his gallery and his obituarists all report it, and he is not on record stating it.
The markA day written down, with one thing made on it and kept, and no score attached.
The deadlineFinished inside the day. It needs no belief, no state and no theory, and works on a person who thinks the rest is nonsense.
The missesBuild the record so it can show a failure without ending, or you have built a machine for quitting.

There is no promise here to test. The one gap is between admiring the file and keeping it, and the four people who kept it said what it cost them, in print.

Use it: the free toolDate →One mark you define once and then cannot change. No streak, no total, and deliberately the least interesting page on the hub.

David Zwirner · Farago 2015 · Opalka statements · Gleeson 2026 · Lippard 1973 · Season 12

Index

All twelve on one map

Across: what it costs to do. Up: how well the research backs it. Color: how far the popular version runs ahead. Tap a practice to jump to its card.

Cheap and thin, one instrument above the line, and no 2 in the gap column

Hype gap: 1 small 2 moderate 3 large 4 extreme

Seven practices sit at cost 1 or 2 and evidence 1 or 2. Only the timed scale reaches evidence 3, and none reaches 4. Eleven practices sit at hype 3 or 4 and one at 1, with nothing at 2. Ratings are one reader's judgment on the series' own scales, argued row by row in the Volume Seven matrix. They don't rate how well anything works for you.