← Study

Form

What does this material ask for?
The question to ask is about the material, not about you. This page is one screen and not a tool, on purpose: there is no questionnaire here, no type and no profile, because those are the parts the season takes apart.

The question

When you sit down to learn something, ask what form the thing itself demands, and give it that form. A map wants to be seen. A melody wants to be heard. In 2005 Daniel Willingham put it in one line: teach to “the content's best modality,” because “modality matters in the same way for all students.”

The 2008 paper that took the learning styles apart conceded geometry to the picture, and said that finding the best form for each subject “is an empirical question.”

The preference

Nobody disputes that people like some formats more than others. A favorite mode “often reveals itself to be instead a preference for tasks for which one has high ability and at which one feels successful,” in Riener and Willingham's words. That is useful to know about yourself. It is not a reason to avoid the hard format, and it may be a reason to practice it.

The author of the best-known questionnaire called it “a catalyst for metacognition, not a diagnostic or a measure.”

What to use instead

What the record says. From the last episode of Study 12: The Styles: “Drop the type. Drop the letters, the profile, the three-fifths, the word that tells a child what kind of learner she is. Drop the matching.” “So carry the question the questionnaire skipped. Not what kind of learner am I. What does this material ask for.”
Why this works, in one picture →
Card 12 of the Study Playbook: the test that would show matching works, what happened when it was run on fifth graders, and who still believes it