For whoever keeps the list: the standing questions asked at every meeting, and the one question announced tonight and argued next time, with the date it was announced. It keeps the date and the question. It does not record who won.
The standing questions
Asked at every meeting, whether or not anyone has an answer. The first two are from the list printed in 1779. Remove them or add your own.
The 1732 proposals put a pause after each question, long enough to fill a glass.
Next meeting's question
Franklin's members heard their questions the week before they argued them, and went home to read.
The rule at the table
No flat contradiction, and no word that imports a fixed opinion: not "certainly," not "undoubtedly." Disagree in a way that lets the other person change their mind.
Questions argued
What the record says. Here is how much the record will hold. A club of tradesmen met on Friday nights for something close to forty years, by its founder's count. Its members founded a library that still exists and a fire company, and its founder kept, for half a century, a habit of not saying "certainly." Everything about its effect on the men in it comes from the one who did best. There is no trial. That is a thin record, and it is a true one.