← Company

Evaluation

Five minutes and a slip
For the timer and the evaluator: a clock that shows green at five minutes, yellow at six and red at seven, big enough to hold up to the speaker, and a written slip the speaker takes home. The slip has no grade, no score and no rating box.

The timer

Ready
0:00

The slip

The judgment is a member's, said in front of the people who heard the talk, and written down so the speaker carries it home.

Slips kept

What the record says. The fear it addresses is real and common, mostly mild, and treatable by methods the room resembles. The organization says, by its own account, that the practice builds confidence. Treatments that look something like the club have dozens of trials behind them. The club itself has none that I could find, and a resemblance is not a result. The timed talk, the evaluation and the dated record are supported as practices kept for a century by the people who did them, not as tested treatments.
Why this works, in one picture →
Card 4 of the Company Playbook: where "more feared than death" came from, how common the fear is, and why a resemblance is not a result.